Решением Шилкинского районного суда от 28 августа 2019 года удовлетворено исковое заявление администрации сельского поселения «Размахнинское» муниципального района «Шилкинский район», которым пенсионер органов внутренних дел, участник боевых действий Дейхин Н.Б. и его семья выселены из занимаемой квартиры, принадлежащей на праве собственности администрации поселения.
Межрайонная прокуратура изучила указанное судебное решение и не согласилась с выводами районного суда.
Установлено, что в 2001 году Дейхину Н.Б. предоставлено спорное жилое помещение, как участковому-уполномоченному ОМВД России по Шилкинскому району.
На момент вселения Дейхина Н.Б. в квартиру, спорное жилое помещение принадлежало на праве собственности ОАО «Забайкальская железная дорога», и лишь в 2003 году передано в муниципальную собственность.
Передача служебного жилья, принадлежащего организации, в муниципальную собственность, влечет утрату служебного статуса и к такому жилью применяется правовой режим, установленный для жилых помещений, предоставляемых по договорам социального найма.
Указанная правовая позиция, сформулированная Верховным судом в обзорах законодательства и судебной практики за 1 квартал 2006 года, не утратила актуальности, и применятся к аналогичным правоотношениям в настоящее время.
Данное правовое регулирование судом первой инстанции во внимание не принято, в связи с чем, межрайонная прокуратура на анализируемое решение принесла апелляционное представление.
По результатам рассмотрения апелляционного представления прокурора, судебной коллегией по гражданским делам Забайкальского краевого суда по делу принято новое решение, которым за Дейхиным Н.Б. и членами его семьи признано право пользования спорным жилым помещением, на администрацию сельского поселения «Размахнинское» возложена обязанность заключить договор социального найма с Дейхиным Н.Б. и членами его семьи. Жилищные права граждан восстановлены. Решение суда вступило в законную силу.


Старший помощник межрайпрокурора

Б.С. Ринчинов

11.658MBMemory Usage94.33msRequest Duration
Joomla! Version5.2.4
PHP Version8.1.29
Identityguest
Response200
Templatecassiopeia
Database
Server
mysql
Version
8.0.22-13
Collation
utf8mb4_general_ci
Conn Collation
utf8mb4_0900_ai_ci
$_GET
[]
$_POST
[]
$_SESSION
array:1 [ "joomla" => "***redacted***" ]
$_COOKIE
[]
$_SERVER
array:39 [ "HTTP_AUTHORIZATION" => "" "HTTP_HOST" => "xn--h1aaaecbes0b2d.xn--p1ai" "HTTP_X_FOR...
session
array:3 [ "counter" => 1 "timer" => array:3 [ "start" => 1741910030 "last" => 1741910030...
registry
array:3 [ "data" => [] "initialized" => false "separator" => "." ]
user
array:21 [ "id" => 0 "name" => null "username" => null "email" => null "password" => "***r...
  • afterLoad (91.04KB) (633μs)
  • afterInitialise (1.59MB) (11.89ms)
  • afterRoute (978.13KB) (4.36ms)
  • beforeRenderComponent com_content (29.24KB) (824μs)
  • Before Access::preloadComponents (all components) (36.91KB) (817μs)
  • After Access::preloadComponents (all components) (121.16KB) (1.13ms)
  • Before Access::preloadPermissions (com_content) (3.88KB) (21μs)
  • After Access::preloadPermissions (com_content) (7.67MB) (20.31ms)
  • Before Access::getAssetRules (id:15026 name:com_content.article.14650) (514.8KB) (563μs)
  • After Access::getAssetRules (id:15026 name:com_content.article.14650) (8.47KB) (92μs)
  • Before Access::getAssetRules (id:1 name:root.1) (388.08KB) (20.29ms)
  • After Access::getAssetRules (id:1 name:root.1) (6.95KB) (66μs)
  • afterRenderComponent com_content (40.02KB) (7.36ms)
  • afterDispatch (2.33KB) (324μs)
  • beforeRenderRawModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (458.5KB) (5.53ms)
  • afterRenderRawModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (63.36KB) (4.16ms)
  • beforeRenderRawModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (4.16KB) (495μs)
  • afterRenderRawModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (14.66KB) (854μs)
  • beforeRenderModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (704B) (11μs)
  • afterRenderModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (3.92KB) (289μs)
  • beforeRenderModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (16.64KB) (810μs)
  • afterRenderModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (3.13KB) (155μs)
  • afterRender (226.01KB) (12.84ms)
  • 1 x After Access::preloadPermissions (com_content) (7.67MB) (21.53%)
    20.31ms
    1 x Before Access::getAssetRules (id:1 name:root.1) (388.08KB) (21.5%)
    20.29ms
    1 x afterRender (226.01KB) (13.62%)
    12.84ms
    1 x afterInitialise (1.59MB) (12.6%)
    11.89ms
    1 x afterRenderComponent com_content (40.02KB) (7.8%)
    7.36ms
    1 x beforeRenderRawModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (458.5KB) (5.87%)
    5.53ms
    1 x afterRoute (978.13KB) (4.63%)
    4.36ms
    1 x afterRenderRawModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (63.36KB) (4.4%)
    4.16ms
    1 x After Access::preloadComponents (all components) (121.16KB) (1.2%)
    1.13ms
    1 x afterRenderRawModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (14.66KB) (0.91%)
    854μs
    1 x beforeRenderComponent com_content (29.24KB) (0.87%)
    824μs
    1 x Before Access::preloadComponents (all components) (36.91KB) (0.87%)
    817μs
    1 x beforeRenderModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (16.64KB) (0.86%)
    810μs
    1 x afterLoad (91.04KB) (0.67%)
    633μs
    1 x Before Access::getAssetRules (id:15026 name:com_content.article.14650) (514.8KB) (0.6%)
    563μs
    1 x beforeRenderRawModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (4.16KB) (0.52%)
    495μs
    1 x afterDispatch (2.33KB) (0.34%)
    324μs
    1 x afterRenderModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (3.92KB) (0.31%)
    289μs
    1 x afterRenderModule mod_finder (ПОИСК) (3.13KB) (0.16%)
    155μs
    1 x After Access::getAssetRules (id:15026 name:com_content.article.14650) (8.47KB) (0.1%)
    92μs
    1 x After Access::getAssetRules (id:1 name:root.1) (6.95KB) (0.07%)
    66μs
    1 x Before Access::preloadPermissions (com_content) (3.88KB) (0.02%)
    21μs
    1 x beforeRenderModule mod_breadcrumbs (Breadcrumbs) (704B) (0.01%)
    11μs
25 statements were executed, 5 of which were duplicates, 20 unique21.24ms871.8KB
  • SELECT @@SESSION.sql_mode;83μs1.57KB/libraries/vendor/joomla/database/src/Mysqli/MysqliDriver.php:308Copy
  • SELECT `data` FROM `cms_session` WHERE `session_id` = ?160μs1.61KBParams/libraries/vendor/joomla/session/src/Handler/DatabaseHandler.php:250Copy
  • SELECT `session_id` FROM `cms_session` WHERE `session_id` = :session_id LIMIT 1105μs1.61KBParams/libraries/src/Session/MetadataManager.php:187Copy
  • INSERT INTO `cms_session` (`session_id`,`guest`,`time`,`userid`,`username`,`client_id`) VALUES (:session_id, :guest, :time, :user_id, :username, :client_id)232μs944BParams/libraries/src/Session/MetadataManager.php:260Copy
  • SELECT `id`,`rules` FROM `cms_viewlevels`140μs1.58KB/libraries/src/Access/Access.php:955Copy
  • SELECT `b`.`id` FROM `cms_usergroups` AS `a` LEFT JOIN `cms_usergroups` AS `b` ON `b`.`lft` <= `a`.`lft` AND `b`.`rgt` >= `a`.`rgt` WHERE `a`.`id` = :guest237μs1.64KBParams/libraries/src/Access/Access.php:868Copy
  • SELECT `c`.`id`,`c`.`asset_id`,`c`.`access`,`c`.`alias`,`c`.`checked_out`,`c`.`checked_out_time`,`c`.`created_time`,`c`.`created_user_id`,`c`.`description`,`c`.`extension`,`c`.`hits`,`c`.`language`,`c`.`level`,`c`.`lft`,`c`.`metadata`,`c`.`metadesc`,`c`.`metakey`,`c`.`modified_time`,`c`.`note`,`c`.`params`,`c`.`parent_id`,`c`.`path`,`c`.`published`,`c`.`rgt`,`c`.`title`,`c`.`modified_user_id`,`c`.`version`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`c`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `c`.`id`, `c`.`alias`) ELSE `c`.`id` END as `slug` FROM `cms_categories` AS `s` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON (`s`.`lft` <= `c`.`lft` AND `c`.`lft` < `s`.`rgt`) OR (`c`.`lft` < `s`.`lft` AND `s`.`rgt` < `c`.`rgt`) WHERE (`c`.`extension` = :extension OR `c`.`extension` = 'system') AND `c`.`published` = 1 AND `s`.`id` = :id ORDER BY `c`.`lft`777μs5.13KBParams/libraries/src/Categories/Categories.php:375Copy
  • SELECT `id`,`name`,`rules`,`parent_id` FROM `cms_assets` WHERE `name` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2,:preparedArray3,:preparedArray4,:preparedArray5,:preparedArray6,:preparedArray7,:preparedArray8,:preparedArray9,:preparedArray10,:preparedArray11,:preparedArray12,:preparedArray13,:preparedArray14,:preparedArray15,:preparedArray16,:preparedArray17,:preparedArray18,:preparedArray19,:preparedArray20,:preparedArray21,:preparedArray22,:preparedArray23,:preparedArray24,:preparedArray25,:preparedArray26,:preparedArray27,:preparedArray28,:preparedArray29,:preparedArray30,:preparedArray31,:preparedArray32,:preparedArray33,:preparedArray34,:preparedArray35,:preparedArray36,:preparedArray37,:preparedArray38)668μs7.75KBParams/libraries/src/Access/Access.php:357Copy
  • SELECT `id`,`name`,`rules`,`parent_id` FROM `cms_assets` WHERE `name` LIKE :asset OR `name` = :extension OR `parent_id` = 08.58ms675.05KBParams/libraries/src/Access/Access.php:301Copy
  • SHOW FULL COLUMNS FROM `cms_content`1.29ms2.39KB/libraries/vendor/joomla/database/src/Mysqli/MysqliDriver.php:587Copy
  • UPDATE `cms_content` SET `hits` = (`hits` + 1) WHERE `id` = '14650'266μs48B/libraries/src/Table/Table.php:1348Copy
  • SELECT `a`.`id`,`a`.`asset_id`,`a`.`title`,`a`.`alias`,`a`.`introtext`,`a`.`fulltext`,`a`.`state`,`a`.`catid`,`a`.`created`,`a`.`created_by`,`a`.`created_by_alias`,`a`.`modified`,`a`.`modified_by`,`a`.`checked_out`,`a`.`checked_out_time`,`a`.`publish_up`,`a`.`publish_down`,`a`.`images`,`a`.`urls`,`a`.`attribs`,`a`.`version`,`a`.`ordering`,`a`.`metakey`,`a`.`metadesc`,`a`.`access`,`a`.`hits`,`a`.`metadata`,`a`.`featured`,`a`.`language`,`fp`.`featured_up`,`fp`.`featured_down`,`c`.`title` AS `category_title`,`c`.`alias` AS `category_alias`,`c`.`access` AS `category_access`,`c`.`language` AS `category_language`,`fp`.`ordering`,`u`.`name` AS `author`,`parent`.`title` AS `parent_title`,`parent`.`id` AS `parent_id`,`parent`.`path` AS `parent_route`,`parent`.`alias` AS `parent_alias`,`parent`.`language` AS `parent_language`,ROUND(`v`.`rating_sum` / `v`.`rating_count`, 1) AS `rating`,`v`.`rating_count` AS `rating_count` FROM `cms_content` AS `a` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON `c`.`id` = `a`.`catid` LEFT JOIN `cms_content_frontpage` AS `fp` ON `fp`.`content_id` = `a`.`id` LEFT JOIN `cms_users` AS `u` ON `u`.`id` = `a`.`created_by` LEFT JOIN `cms_categories` AS `parent` ON `parent`.`id` = `c`.`parent_id` LEFT JOIN `cms_content_rating` AS `v` ON `a`.`id` = `v`.`content_id` WHERE ( (`a`.`id` = :pk AND `c`.`published` > 0) AND (`a`.`publish_up` IS NULL OR `a`.`publish_up` <= :publishUp)) AND (`a`.`publish_down` IS NULL OR `a`.`publish_down` >= :publishDown) AND `a`.`state` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2)650μs24.63KBParams/components/com_content/src/Model/ArticleModel.php:215Copy
  • SELECT `c`.`id`,`c`.`asset_id`,`c`.`access`,`c`.`alias`,`c`.`checked_out`,`c`.`checked_out_time`,`c`.`created_time`,`c`.`created_user_id`,`c`.`description`,`c`.`extension`,`c`.`hits`,`c`.`language`,`c`.`level`,`c`.`lft`,`c`.`metadata`,`c`.`metadesc`,`c`.`metakey`,`c`.`modified_time`,`c`.`note`,`c`.`params`,`c`.`parent_id`,`c`.`path`,`c`.`published`,`c`.`rgt`,`c`.`title`,`c`.`modified_user_id`,`c`.`version`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`c`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `c`.`id`, `c`.`alias`) ELSE `c`.`id` END as `slug` FROM `cms_categories` AS `s` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON (`s`.`lft` <= `c`.`lft` AND `c`.`lft` < `s`.`rgt`) OR (`c`.`lft` < `s`.`lft` AND `s`.`rgt` < `c`.`rgt`) WHERE (`c`.`extension` = :extension OR `c`.`extension` = 'system') AND `c`.`access` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2) AND `c`.`published` = 1 AND `s`.`id` = :id ORDER BY `c`.`lft`720μs5.17KBParams/libraries/src/Categories/Categories.php:375Copy
  • SELECT `m`.`tag_id`,`t`.* FROM `cms_contentitem_tag_map` AS `m` INNER JOIN `cms_tags` AS `t` ON `m`.`tag_id` = `t`.`id` WHERE `m`.`type_alias` = :contentType AND `m`.`content_item_id` = :id AND `t`.`published` = 1 AND `t`.`access` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2)352μs5.22KBParams/libraries/src/Helper/TagsHelper.php:388Copy
  • SELECT `c`.`id`,`c`.`asset_id`,`c`.`access`,`c`.`alias`,`c`.`checked_out`,`c`.`checked_out_time`,`c`.`created_time`,`c`.`created_user_id`,`c`.`description`,`c`.`extension`,`c`.`hits`,`c`.`language`,`c`.`level`,`c`.`lft`,`c`.`metadata`,`c`.`metadesc`,`c`.`metakey`,`c`.`modified_time`,`c`.`note`,`c`.`params`,`c`.`parent_id`,`c`.`path`,`c`.`published`,`c`.`rgt`,`c`.`title`,`c`.`modified_user_id`,`c`.`version`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`c`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `c`.`id`, `c`.`alias`) ELSE `c`.`id` END as `slug` FROM `cms_categories` AS `s` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON (`s`.`lft` <= `c`.`lft` AND `c`.`lft` < `s`.`rgt`) OR (`c`.`lft` < `s`.`lft` AND `s`.`rgt` < `c`.`rgt`) WHERE (`c`.`extension` = :extension OR `c`.`extension` = 'system') AND `c`.`access` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2) AND `c`.`published` = 1 AND `s`.`id` = :id ORDER BY `c`.`lft`683μs5.17KBParams/libraries/src/Categories/Categories.php:375Copy
  • SELECT DISTINCT a.id, a.title, a.name, a.checked_out, a.checked_out_time, a.note, a.state, a.access, a.created_time, a.created_user_id, a.ordering, a.language, a.fieldparams, a.params, a.type, a.default_value, a.context, a.group_id, a.label, a.description, a.required, a.only_use_in_subform,l.title AS language_title, l.image AS language_image,uc.name AS editor,ag.title AS access_level,ua.name AS author_name,g.title AS group_title, g.access as group_access, g.state AS group_state, g.note as group_note FROM cms_fields AS a LEFT JOIN `cms_languages` AS l ON l.lang_code = a.language LEFT JOIN cms_users AS uc ON uc.id=a.checked_out LEFT JOIN cms_viewlevels AS ag ON ag.id = a.access LEFT JOIN cms_users AS ua ON ua.id = a.created_user_id LEFT JOIN cms_fields_groups AS g ON g.id = a.group_id LEFT JOIN `cms_fields_categories` AS fc ON fc.field_id = a.id WHERE ( (`a`.`context` = :context AND (`fc`.`category_id` IS NULL OR `fc`.`category_id` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2,:preparedArray3)) AND `a`.`access` IN (:preparedArray4,:preparedArray5)) AND (`a`.`group_id` = 0 OR `g`.`access` IN (:preparedArray6,:preparedArray7)) AND `a`.`state` = :state) AND (`a`.`group_id` = 0 OR `g`.`state` = :gstate) AND `a`.`only_use_in_subform` = :only_use_in_subform ORDER BY a.ordering ASC575μs6.06KBParams/libraries/src/MVC/Model/BaseDatabaseModel.php:164Copy
  • SELECT `a`.`id`,`a`.`title`,`a`.`catid`,`a`.`language`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`a`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `a`.`id`, `a`.`alias`) ELSE a.id END AS `slug`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`cc`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `cc`.`id`, `cc`.`alias`) ELSE cc.id END AS `catslug` FROM `cms_content` AS `a` LEFT JOIN `cms_categories` AS `cc` ON `cc`.`id` = `a`.`catid` WHERE `a`.`catid` = :catid AND `a`.`state` = :state AND `a`.`access` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2) AND (`publish_up` IS NULL OR `publish_up` <= :nowDate1) AND (`publish_down` IS NULL OR `publish_down` >= :nowDate2) ORDER BY CASE WHEN `a`.`publish_up` IS NULL THEN `a`.`created` ELSE `a`.`publish_up` END DESC2.4ms88.53KBParams/plugins/content/pagenavigation/src/Extension/PageNavigation.php:188Copy
  • SELECT `c`.`id`,`c`.`asset_id`,`c`.`access`,`c`.`alias`,`c`.`checked_out`,`c`.`checked_out_time`,`c`.`created_time`,`c`.`created_user_id`,`c`.`description`,`c`.`extension`,`c`.`hits`,`c`.`language`,`c`.`level`,`c`.`lft`,`c`.`metadata`,`c`.`metadesc`,`c`.`metakey`,`c`.`modified_time`,`c`.`note`,`c`.`params`,`c`.`parent_id`,`c`.`path`,`c`.`published`,`c`.`rgt`,`c`.`title`,`c`.`modified_user_id`,`c`.`version`, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(`c`.`alias`) != 0 THEN CONCAT_WS(':', `c`.`id`, `c`.`alias`) ELSE `c`.`id` END as `slug` FROM `cms_categories` AS `s` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON (`s`.`lft` <= `c`.`lft` AND `c`.`lft` < `s`.`rgt`) OR (`c`.`lft` < `s`.`lft` AND `s`.`rgt` < `c`.`rgt`) WHERE (`c`.`extension` = :extension OR `c`.`extension` = 'system') AND `c`.`access` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2) AND `c`.`published` = 1 AND `s`.`id` = :id ORDER BY `c`.`lft`900μs5.17KBParams/libraries/src/Categories/Categories.php:375Copy
  • SELECT `name`,`element` FROM `cms_extensions` WHERE `type` = 'plugin' AND `folder` = 'finder' AND `enabled` = 1342μs944B/administrator/components/com_finder/src/Helper/LanguageHelper.php:135Copy
  • SELECT `title` FROM `cms_finder_taxonomy` WHERE `parent_id` = 1 AND `state` = 1 AND `access` IN (1,5)232μs936B/administrator/components/com_finder/src/Indexer/Taxonomy.php:325Copy
  • SELECT * FROM `cms_schemaorg` WHERE `itemId` = :itemId AND `context` = :context266μs1.86KBParams/plugins/system/schemaorg/src/Extension/Schemaorg.php:403Copy
  • SELECT `a`.`id`,`a`.`asset_id`,`a`.`title`,`a`.`alias`,`a`.`introtext`,`a`.`fulltext`,`a`.`state`,`a`.`catid`,`a`.`created`,`a`.`created_by`,`a`.`created_by_alias`,`a`.`modified`,`a`.`modified_by`,`a`.`checked_out`,`a`.`checked_out_time`,`a`.`publish_up`,`a`.`publish_down`,`a`.`images`,`a`.`urls`,`a`.`attribs`,`a`.`version`,`a`.`ordering`,`a`.`metakey`,`a`.`metadesc`,`a`.`access`,`a`.`hits`,`a`.`metadata`,`a`.`featured`,`a`.`language`,`fp`.`featured_up`,`fp`.`featured_down`,`c`.`title` AS `category_title`,`c`.`alias` AS `category_alias`,`c`.`access` AS `category_access`,`c`.`language` AS `category_language`,`fp`.`ordering`,`u`.`name` AS `author`,`parent`.`title` AS `parent_title`,`parent`.`id` AS `parent_id`,`parent`.`path` AS `parent_route`,`parent`.`alias` AS `parent_alias`,`parent`.`language` AS `parent_language`,ROUND(`v`.`rating_sum` / `v`.`rating_count`, 1) AS `rating`,`v`.`rating_count` AS `rating_count` FROM `cms_content` AS `a` INNER JOIN `cms_categories` AS `c` ON `c`.`id` = `a`.`catid` LEFT JOIN `cms_content_frontpage` AS `fp` ON `fp`.`content_id` = `a`.`id` LEFT JOIN `cms_users` AS `u` ON `u`.`id` = `a`.`created_by` LEFT JOIN `cms_categories` AS `parent` ON `parent`.`id` = `c`.`parent_id` LEFT JOIN `cms_content_rating` AS `v` ON `a`.`id` = `v`.`content_id` WHERE ( (`a`.`id` = :pk AND `c`.`published` > 0) AND (`a`.`publish_up` IS NULL OR `a`.`publish_up` <= :publishUp)) AND (`a`.`publish_down` IS NULL OR `a`.`publish_down` >= :publishDown) AND `a`.`state` IN (:preparedArray1,:preparedArray2)840μs24.67KBParams/components/com_content/src/Model/ArticleModel.php:215Copy
  • SELECT SUM(CASE WHEN `a`.`next_execution` <= :now THEN 1 ELSE 0 END) AS due_count,SUM(CASE WHEN `a`.`locked` IS NULL THEN 0 ELSE 1 END) AS locked_count FROM `cms_scheduler_tasks` AS `a` WHERE `a`.`state` = 1230μs1.68KBParams/administrator/components/com_scheduler/src/Model/TasksModel.php:517Copy
  • SELECT `session_id` FROM `cms_session` WHERE `session_id` = ?156μs1.63KBParams/libraries/vendor/joomla/session/src/Handler/DatabaseHandler.php:277Copy
  • UPDATE `cms_session` SET `data` = ? , `time` = ? WHERE `session_id` = ?358μs912BParams/libraries/vendor/joomla/session/src/Handler/DatabaseHandler.php:301Copy

XПанель доступности